O Brother Where Art Thou And The Odyssey Essay

Comparing "The Odyssey" And "O Brother Where Art Thou"

"Tell me, O muse..." (Page 1), is a quote used in the beginning of both The Odyssey and "O Brother Where Art Thou". The funny thing about this is that the directors of the movie "O Brother Where Art Thou" (Joel and Ethan Coen) never even read The Odyssey before making this film. Though not identical the movie contained several similarities to The Odyssey. Examples of these can be seen by the interactions with the sirens, encounters with one-eyed opponents and the initial shunning of our heroes by their wives upon their return.

"First you will come to the sirens, who enchant all who come near them. If anyone unwarily draws in too close and hears the singing of the Sirens, his wife and children will never welcome him home again."(Page 163)This is the warning foretold by Circe to Odysseus in The Odyssey. Circe explained to Odysseus that the only way to escape the Sirens was by putting wax in his crew's ears and having his crew tie Odysseus up to the mast of the ship until they pass the Sirens. Odysseus follows Circes advice and passes the Sirens unscathed. Just like in The Odyssey the Sirens use their singing to lure in Everett, Pete and Delmar down by the lake in "O Brother Where Art Thou". The difference between the Sirens in the book verses the movie is that in The Odyssey, Odysseus is able to pass the sirens. In "O Brother Where Art Thou", Everett and his "crew" are unable to escape the sirens temptations. Pete was unfortunately captured and sent back to prison.

Another similarity between The Odyssey and "O Brother Where Art Thou" are the Cyclops. In The Odyssey, Odysseus and his crew lands on the Island of the Cyclopes and discovers a large cave. They enter into the cave and feast on food they find within. This cave is the home of Polyphemus, an evil Cyclops, who soon returns and traps Odysseus and his crew in the cave. This monster proceeds to eat several of...

Loading: Checking Spelling


Read more

The Film "O brother, where art thou?"

1046 words - 4 pages The Film "O brother, where art thou?" The film O brother, where art thou? is set in the Great Depression of the 1930’s and emphasizes the struggle between the upper and lower classes by using a variety of cinematic devices. Through the use of these cinematic devices and comedic relief the realities of the Depression are viewed without creating a stark, melancholy, documentary-styled film. Examples in this film of these cinematic devices...

Rhetorical Paper O brother where art thou

781 words - 3 pages Aguilar 1Jonathan AguilarProfessor CannonCritical Thinking and Writing 113October 13, 2014 Comparison PaperO brother, where art thou? which is a story based off the classic epic The Odyssey, revolving around three men who escaped from prison and are now looking for a treasure, but along the way they come across many different obstacles such as missing a train, a...

The Odyssey in Oh Brother, Where Art Thou

897 words - 4 pages The Odyssey in Oh Brother, Where Art Thou The movie O Brother, Where Art Thou is a wonderful movie that was directed by the Coen brothers. The movie features a cast of talented actors, the movie has also won several awards. The book The Odyssey is a timeless classic and it was written by the mysterious bard Homer. The book tells the tale of our hero Odysseus as he attempts to make it home to his wife. There are many ways to relate the...

O brother where art thou, and the Odyssey Prompt: Creatures encountered in the film and the text- how are they similar/ different?

1519 words - 6 pages When the film O Bother Where Art Thou first started, I was unable to make any correlation between that and The Odyssey, but as it progressed I soon was able to follow the plot and match creatures to their ancient Greek counterparts. As Odysseus encountered many monsters, mystical creatures, and gods, Ulysses (the main Odysseus like character in O Bother...

Elements of Homer's Odyssey in the Coen Brothers' Oh Brother Where Art Thou

652 words - 3 pages The Coen Brothers’ “Oh Brother Where Art Thou?”, loosely based on Homer’s classic adventure The Odyssey, is a film amusingly filled with themes of symbolism similar to those found in Homer’s epic, while still maintaining a sense of originality and style that they have become so renowned for. An exciting and entertaining blend of high adventure, humour, and heartfelt emotion, at first glance, the film barely resembles Homer’s poem: only certain...

O Brother, Where Art Thou? - From Greek Classic to American Original

3221 words - 13 pages O Brother, Where Art Thou? - From Greek Classic to American Original In the winter of 2001, American audiences initially paid little attention to Joel and Ethan Coen's Depression era, jail-break, musical "buddy" comedy O Brother, Where Art Thou? The film's reputation lingered, however, and over the next seven months O Brother eventually grossed a significant $45.5 million (imdb.com). Loosely adapted from Homer’s The Odyssey, the film...

“O, Romeo, Romeo! wherefore art thou Romeo?”: Is love the same as it was over 400 years ago?

2651 words - 11 pages I have fallen in love before with a very good friend of mine. We spent so much of our time together. We were completely infatuated with each other. What would our relationship have been like 400 years ago? Would we have ever even met? I like to think that we would have, but what if we had not? Relationships between a man and woman have changed so much over the past centuries. The problem is that they have not changed for the better; they have...

Comparing the Odyssey and Medea

1527 words - 6 pages While home is usually represented by a physical shelter such as a house, Homer and Euripides in their respective novels The Odyssey and Medea show that home has much more significance as a state where one can comfortably express the values and beliefs that define one’s identity. Both authors use protagonists who are far away from home. These characters often associate with and depend upon other characters they meet. Since they live under the...

Comparing the Aeneid and the Odyssey

2917 words - 12 pages   Both the Odyssey and the Aeneid represent their cultures very well, but they express different ideas on what one should strive for in life.  There are also different forces that pushed both epics to be written.  The Aeneid expresses the Roman idea of pietas which means to show extreme respect for one’s ancestors. We see this in Aeneas when he is pictured caring his father away from burning Troy.  He has pietas because he cared so much for his...

The Art of Hospitality - The Greeks and the Odyssey

885 words - 4 pages Each culture treats strangers and guests with distinct differences from every other culture. One of the most hospitable cultures was that of the ancient Greeks, exemplified in Homer’s The Odyssey by both gracious hosts and guests. In Greece and The Odyssey, not only was good hospitality etiquette expected, but the added pressure from the conviction that the gods would punish the host if guests were treated without respect (whether they were poor...

Comparing the Deceitful Women of Homer's Odyssey and the Bible

1278 words - 5 pages The Deceitful Women of Homer's Odyssey and the Bible Across all barriers, women have always brought pain, suffering, and aguish to the men as demonstrated in both Homer's Odyssey and the Bible. With their beauty and grace, temptresses like the Sirens and Delilah lure men into their grasps, only to later steer them to their ruin. Other times, they use their cunning abilities and deception, as Circe and Jezebel did, in order to entice men...

O, Brother, Where Art Thou Compared to The Odyssey

O, Brother is on the left hand side; Odyssey on the right.
Blind railroad conductor prophesizes the future of the main characters.
Tiresias prophesizes the future of Odysseus and his crew in Land of the Dead.
Ulysuss Evert McGee: Cunning, quick-tongued, sharp, leader, wants to go home and see his family.
Odysseus: Cunning, quick-tongued, sharp, leader, wants to go home to see his family.
Characters disguised as KKK to free Tommy.
Odysseus and his crew hide under the sheep to escape from Polyphemus.
Big Dan T's death by the flaming, wooden cross.
Polyphemus' blindness caused by the flaming spear.
Evert's constant concern for his hair. (Use of hair products and hair nets, his pride.)
Odysseus' pride and tragic flaw.
Singing about their lives for money.
Odysseus telling King Alcinous about his tale for a ship ride home.
Pete and Delmar: Go along with everything Evert suggests, Pete ends up going to jail again and all three become outlaws because of it.
Odysseus' crew: Go along with everything Odysseus suggests, end up dead because of it.
Wear beards/disguises to sneak into political rally so Evert can talk to Penny.
Odysseus is disguised by Athena so he may talk to Penny at his house without the suitors knowing.
The baptizing scene: Pete and Delmar repent their sins, while Evert does not. They feel happy and forget about the treasure for awhile.
The Lotus Eater: Some of Odysseus' crew eat the lotus, but Odysseus doesn not. They are happy and forget of home.
Pete's betraying cousin reports the three convicts to the police.
Not directly paralleled, but represents the obstacles that had to be overcome in order to achieve their goal.
Governer Menelaus (Pappy O'Daniel Flower) trying to maintain control.
Three girls singing in the river
Big Dan T has one eye; "kills their friend"; attacks them.
Polyphemus, the cyclops; kills crew members; attacks them all.
The sheriff in pursuit of the escaped convicts.
Zeus getting angry with the crew and killing them... I think.
The three Harvey girls don't recognize their Father. Even when Evert tells them it's him, they don't believe him.
Telemachus doesn't recognize his own Father while he's disguised, and even when Odysseus reveals himself, Telemachus is still in disbelief and thinks that it is a God.
Penny: Loves Evert but almost decides on Vernon. Although, in the end, she decides on Evert. Refused to acknowledge he was there.
Penelope: Loves Odysseus but decides to hold a contest for the suitors, but she ends up with Odysseus. Refused to believe it was actually him.
Evert has to get the wedding rings in order to marry Penny.
Categories: 1

0 Replies to “O Brother Where Art Thou And The Odyssey Essay”

Leave a comment

L'indirizzo email non verrà pubblicato. I campi obbligatori sono contrassegnati *